“Everything that can be counted does not necessarily count; everything that counts cannot necessarily be counted.” Albert Einstein

Sunday, September 5, 2010

The Wax Paper: Home Birth Science or Propaganda?


The Wax Paper: Home Birth Science or Propaganda?

Home Birth Science or Propaganda?

Studies, like the Wax Paper, that include high-risk ACCIDENTAL out-of-hospital births are going to show worse outcomes than studies that exclusively evaluate low-risk PLANNED out of hospital births with a skilled midwife. These more relevant studies show no difference in risk to the baby.

If someone tells you about a study that shows higher rates of deaths for babies born at home please ask them if they are comparing apples to oranges.

Specifically:

  1. Does the data in this study include ACCIDENTAL out-of-hospital birth?
  2. Why should that make me vote against PLANNED out-of-hospital births with midwives?
  3. Doesn't this study really mean that I SHOULD vote for this bill, to make sure women PLANNING out-of-hospital births have access to midwives.
  4. Why are you trying to trick me by mixing apples and oranges without telling me about the oranges?

Don't be fooled by BAD SCIENCE that
Compares APPLES to ORANGES

No comments:

Post a Comment